Sample Education Paper on Academic Integrity Scenarios

According to the International Center for Academic Integrity, academic integrity is defined as
the commitment to the five fundamental values that guide the ethical practice of scholarly
actions. The five values; honesty, respect, fairness, trust and responsibility form the basis of all
academic integrity needs (International Center for Academic Integrity | Cultivating Integrity
Worldwide, n.d.) . Globally, the principles and concepts that underly academic integrity have
been embraced. The embrace can be attributed to each stake holder in the academic institutions
including administration, teaching stuff and the students understand that the scholarly goals of
learning, research and teaching are best achieved when the ethical standards are upheld. Most
learning institutions have come up with an Ethics committee that is responsible for ensuring that
the values of academic integrity are upheld at all times. For this essay, we are going to look at
the scenario of a student-kai- an international student who has been caught at the cross roads. He
is torn between compromising on the academic integrity and feeling sorry for another student
who seems not to be as prepared for the assignment. The paper will critically evaluate the role of
each stakeholder which involves both students, Dean of Students, topic coordinator and the
academic registrar in the said scenario. Additionally, the essay will seek to address the
implications and management of the issue if arises.
Kai and the friends are taking the same courses, they have an assignment that Is due the next day.
Kai is more confident and prepared to take on the assignments. The friends on the other hand, as
much as they meet to discuss the progress of the studies is not feeling as confident as Kai. They
have low confidence of their proficiency in English and generally the study. Therefore, feeling
like they are underconfident, they want to ask Kai to help out with the assignment. By so doing,
the students are willing to compromise on the values of honesty, responsibility and fairness.
They want to delegate responsibility and are willing to compete unfairly with others. A study

ACADEMIC INTEGRITY SCENARIOS 3
(Academic integrity and plagiarism: A review of the influences and risk situations for health
students: Higher Education Research & Development: Vol 32, No 3, n.d.-a) has stated that the
involve of an individual or individuals in the breach of academic integrity has to be looked at as
the complex issue that it is. It has to take into account the risks and factors that are the driving
goal into the entertainment of the taught. Another study by (Bretag et al., n.d.) suggests that
among other things, lack of understanding of what academic dishonesty involves, the
repercussions of academic dishonest, peer pressure and performance anxiety are some of the
drivers towards academic dishonesty. In the case of Ki and friends, its evident that in as much as
the friends are unprepared, they are anxious that they need to perform. However, they are
unwilling to take the correct route. Kai on the other hand is prepared and ready to take on the
assignment. On the flipside, Kai is threading on a dangerous path. Peer pressure ranks very high
in the list of influences that cause academic dishonesty. Therefore, by not standing the ground
and explaining to the friends the essence of academic integrity. Besides, someone can argue that
Kai and the friends are unaware of the consequences of academic dishonesty.
A paper by (Scanlan, 2006) has noted that in academic integrity promotion every stake holder
has a role in promoting academic integrity. Each player, the student, the administration and the
ethics committee have a hand in enforcing the standards of academic honesty. Take Kai’s case
for example, the students have failed in terms of standing by the values. However, in assessing
the situation objectively there must be a look into the role of the institution in ensuring the
academic integrity is upheld. The institution has three key players in the scene; the topic
coordinator, the dean of students’ and the academic integrity transfer. The publication (Academic
Integrity as an Institutional Issue: Ethics & Behavior: Vol 11, No 3, n.d.) argues that the
institution and the leaders have a role in ensuring academic integrity. The dean of students and

ACADEMIC INTEGRITY SCENARIOS 4
the academic integrity registrar are tasked with coming up with strict but fair policies on
academic integrity. Besides, they are the people tasked with creating programs and sensitization
forums that are educative and equally informative to let the students know of the policies that
they come up with. Additionally, the institution should be able to provide support, resources and
information relevant to aid the students in their pursuit of quality education. Though on the
hypothetical value, the course educator might have played a role in the student feeling
insufficient. Therefore, every topic coordinator has to educate the learners and prepare them to
feel sufficient for assignments, exams and any assessment.
In every institution, there is a person responsible for Academic integrity. In the case of Flinders
university there is the academic integrity registrar. His aim is to achieve 100% academic
integrity. Failure to which, the objectives of learning and the teaching goals are immeasurable. It
is in essence difficult to give each learner what is due to them in terms of the grades during
assessments and assignments if they are not honest. That compromises on the fairness and trust
of the system to deliver well prepared learned to the world. Considering Kai’s case, the students
are training to be nurses. A noble profession that deals with people’s lives. At times, the nurses at
their work stations are the final decision makers on the progress of their patients. For someone
much has been given, so much is expected from them. Therefore, compromising on the integrity
of academic progress can affect their service delivery. Hence, the reason the values need to be
embraced from the early learning stages to the point they become the normal part of their lives.
The scenario in question can actually spin to actual dishonesty. Should that happen, the students
must be punished adequately but fairly as per the policy. Besides, the institution can take it as a
sensitization and information point to aid other students to abide in the academic integrity
guidelines. The students too have a responsibility to seek information and university policy on
the issue of academic integrity.

Conclusively, the issue of academic integrity is a complex but highly rewarding subject.
Therefore, it’s imperative for every player to play their roles and responsibility effectively so as

ACADEMIC INTEGRITY SCENARIOS 5
to ensure that academic integrity is maintained as it’s the best way to achieve the learning and
teaching goals. Additionally, the scholars and their teachers need to appreciate the matter of
academic integrity not as a punishment but as a necessary step to achieving academic goal. The
reason for the appreciation can only be anchored in the adage that where there are morals only
then are laws sufficient. However, on the other hand, where there are no morals law is
impossible to practice. Since understanding the values is an ethical thing, every person needs to
inculcate the values without having in mind the punitive measures that may be used against them
if they don’t. In other words, the issue of academic integrity is one that should come out so
naturally.

ACADEMIC INTEGRITY SCENARIOS 6

References
Academic integrity and plagiarism: A review of the influences and risk situations for health
students: Higher Education Research & Development: Vol 32, No 3. (n.d.-a). Retrieved
March 5, 2020, from
https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/07294360.2012.687362
Academic integrity and plagiarism: A review of the influences and risk situations for health
students: Higher Education Research & Development: Vol 32, No 3. (n.d.-b). Retrieved
March 5, 2020, from
https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/07294360.2012.687362
Academic Integrity as an Institutional Issue: Ethics & Behavior: Vol 11, No 3. (n.d.). Retrieved
March 5, 2020, from
https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1207/S15327019EB1103_9
Bretag, T., Mahmud, S., Wallace, M. C., Walker, R., & James, C. (n.d.). Core elements of
exemplary academic integrity policy in Australian higher education. 11.
Hoffmann, T. C., Montori, V. M., & Mar, C. D. (2014). The Connection Between Evidence-
Based Medicine and Shared Decision Making. JAMA, 312(13), 1295–1296.
https://doi.org/10.1001/jama.2014.10186
International Center for Academic Integrity | Cultivating Integrity Worldwide. (n.d.). Retrieved
March 5, 2020, from https://www.academicintegrity.org/
McCabe, D., & Pavela, G. (2000). Some Good News About Academic Integrity. Change: The
Magazine of Higher Learning, 32(5), 32–38.
https://doi.org/10.1080/00091380009605738

ACADEMIC INTEGRITY SCENARIOS 7
Plagiarism, the Internet, and Student Learning: Improving Academic Integrity—Wendy
Sutherland-Smith—Google Books. (n.d.). Retrieved March 9, 2020, from
https://books.google.co.ke/books?hl=en&lr=&id=RmgRcMR30RsC&oi=fnd&pg=PP1&
dq=academic+integrity&ots=HFrwyRHYca&sig=_v8Z6B1jIpAuUxLjDz9ic_3jDKc&red
ir_esc=y#v=onepage&q=academic%20integrity&f=false
Scanlan, C. L. (2006, Fall). Strategies to Promote a Climate of Academic Integrity and Minimize
Student Cheating and Plagiarism [Text]. Association of Schools of Allied Health
Professions.
https://www.ingentaconnect.com/content/asahp/jah/2006/00000035/00000003/art00010
Strategies to Promote a Climate of Academic Integrity and Minimiz…: Ingenta Connect. (n.d.).
Retrieved March 5, 2020, from
https://www.ingentaconnect.com/content/asahp/jah/2006/00000035/00000003/art00010